Skip to main content

Search the middle of everything...

Shedd Aquarium

Nauvoo’s Old Stone Church

125 South Fulmer, Nauvoo, IL 62354

Vacation Rentals

This building has a remarkable story to tell! It has now been thoroughly renovated, and serves as an elegant vacation home for those visiting Nauvoo, and looking for an historic experience, with all the modern luxuries.

Known as "The Old Stone Church," "The Legion Hall," "The Temple Stone Church," or "The Old Methodist Church," this building has a remarkable story to tell. Every group who has been in what is now Nauvoo, has played a part in its history.

As you walk through the front door you will enter a modern living space with comfortable couches for relaxing and a modern kitchen with premium appliances that will meet the needs of a gourmet cook.

Down the passage and to the left you will enter the master bedroom with a super comfortable king size bed with its ensuite. To the right is the second bedroom with an equally comfortable queen bed. This bedroom has direct access to the main bathroom.

Other facilities include:
*A Baby Bjorn cot is available on request.
*The three televisions all have DirectTV.
*A full-size washing machine and clothes dryer
*Ample off-street parking
*Casey's fuel station right across the road
*An easy stroll to Dollar General Store, Downtown Nauvoo, The Temple, Nauvoo Historic Sites


The land was owned by one of Nauvoo's first landowners, Joseph B. Teas. He purchased the property in 1827. Those who owned the land through the years include Ethan Kimball (brother of Hiram Kimball and cousin of Heber C. Kimball), Peter Fullmer, and Pulaski Cahoon (son of Reynold Cahoon).

A prominent early Nauvoo resident, Adam Swartz soon acquired the property, and it was during his period of ownership that the current building was constructed. The building was constructed prior to 1860 by Michael Baumert (who also constructed the Stone Arch Bridge in Nauvoo). Michael Baumert was an early German immigrant to Nauvoo and was a master stone mason. Initially constructed as the English Methodist Church building, it was constructed with Nauvoo Temple Stone purchased from the Icarian's.

From this we know that much of the building was constructed with Nauvoo Temple stone. One fragment of a star stone is still visible on the exterior.

More Information

  • Air Conditioning
  • Parking Available
  • Heating
  • Wi-Fi Available
  • Free In-Room Wi-Fi

How to find us?

Back to Listings

You might also be interested...

Hart House

Nauvoo

Location, location, location! You can’t stay closer to the Nauvoo Temple than at the Hart House, across the street from the temple! This location has an…

Read more about Hart House

The Mix House

Nauvoo

The historic Nauvoo Mix house is located on Parley street in beautiful Nauvoo, IL. Situated among sprawling Nauvoo farms, this original 1846 historic home enjoys the…

Read more about The Mix House

Gatehouse

Nauvoo

The complete home is three stories, but there is a lock off available on the first floor (Troubadour's Quarters), allowing that unit to be rented separately,…

Read more about Gatehouse

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get inspired by top travel stories, gain access to exclusive promotions and contests, and discover even more reasons to #EnjoyIllinois.